There are many things to do in Blue Hill, Maine, including exploring Blue Hill Peninsula top restaurants. Each restaurant offers a unique dining experience, compelling flavors, and opportunities to create lasting memories.
We love our charming coastal town of Blue Hill, Maine. This hidden gem is known for its breathtaking scenery, warm hospitality, and locally sourced food. Nestled in the heart of this coastal paradise is Blue Hill Inn. Our Inn is the perfect home base to return to after exploring the local culinary scene. You may need to visit more than once to experience all the fantastic creations each of these Blue Hill Peninsula Maine restaurants provides.
* * * * *
Please note that restaurant hours of operation may vary due to seasonal changes, holidays, or unexpected closures.
We recommend contacting the restaurant directly to confirm its current operating hours when planning your visit.
* * * * *
Unique Dining and Cafés Seafood Specialties Fine Dining
UNIQUE DINING AND CAFÉS
1. Bucklyn Coffee — A Coffee Lover’s Paradise
103 Main St, Blue Hill, ME 04614
(917) 971-3246
Less than half a mile from Blue Hill Inn
Before you explore the fantastic Deer Isle restaurants, stop by this café for your caffeine fix. Coffee connoisseurs will be delighted by Bucklyn Coffee, a micro-roaster from Brooklyn. It’s only a 5-minute walk from the Blue Hill Inn. Alongside its small but delightful shop in town, Bucklyn Coffee embraces a love for all things coffee. Take your coffee “to go” while you check out some art and antiques or historic homes and buildings in town.
2. Marlintini’s Bar & Grill — A Hub of Flavor
83 Mines Rd, Blue Hill, ME 04614
(207) 374-2500
About a mile from Blue Hill Inn
Established in 2000, Marlintini’s Bar & Grill has tantalized many taste buds with its diverse menu and relaxing ambiance. This popular local grill, just a 3-minute drive from Blue Hill Inn, offers an array of mouthwatering entrees, burgers, salads, soups, and seafood. Pair your meal with their impressive selection of beers on tap.
3. Barncastle — A Fusion of Seasonal Delights and Alsatian Influences
125 South St, Blue Hill, ME 04614
(207) 374-2300
Just over a mile from Blue Hill Inn
Barncastle offers a blend of seasonal ingredients with Alsatian flair. Their menu has something for everyone, from pretzel rolls to schnitzel to wood-fired oven specialties. Enjoy natural wines, craft beers, and classic cocktails alongside live music.
4. Roaring Lion Farm and Market — A Farm-to-Table Haven Overlooking Pastures
144 Snow’s Cove Rd, Sedgwick, ME 04676
(207) 359-2107
7 miles from Blue Hill Inn
The Roaring Lion Farm and Market offers a farm-to-table experience amidst picturesque pastures. Treat yourself to organic meats, produce, and dairy products overlooking the farm. Enjoy breakfast and lunch featuring weekly ingredients sourced locally. With everything made from scratch, indulge in fresh flavors and support local farmers.
5. Tinder Hearth — A Haven for Wood-Fired Bread and Pizza Enthusiasts
1452 Coastal Rd, Brooksville, ME 04617
(207) 326-8381
About 12 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Tinder Hearth is the best of the Blue Hill, Maine, restaurants for wood-fired bread and pizza perfection. Delight in morning bakery offerings, Saturday brunches featuring farm-fresh ingredients, and evening pizza nights with pizza, salads, and beverages. Whether dining in or taking out, you’ll love savoring the taste of locally sourced ingredients crafted with care.
6. Whale’s Rib Tavern at the Pilgrim’s Inn — Historic Charm Meets Innovative Cuisine
20 Main St, Deer Isle, ME 04627
(207) 348-5222
18 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Whale’s Rib Tavern offers historic charm and innovative cuisine. Enjoy the flavors of Maine while soaking in scenic views in the casual dining room, the tavern, or the outdoor beer garden. With locally sourced ingredients and expertly crafted dishes, there is something for everyone here.
7. Pentagöet Wine Bar — Victorian Elegance Meets Culinary Excellence
26 Main St, Castine, ME 04421
(207) 326-8616
18 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Step into Victorian elegance at Pentagöet Wine Bar. With a seasonal menu and weekly cocktail specials, it’s a haven for food and wine enthusiasts. Enjoy a charming atmosphere and indulge in lobster pot pie and other local fare. Whether for a wine-tasting event or a delightful meal, Pentagöet promises an unforgettable dining experience.
SEAFOOD SPECIALTIES
8. The Maine Lobster Lady — Your Ultimate Destination for Fresh Maine Lobster
209 Caterpillar Hill Rd, Sargentville, ME 04673
(207) 669-2751
About 10 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Experience the essence of Maine’s lobster industry at The Maine Lobster Lady. Indulge in award-winning lobster rolls and other seafood delights. Everything from clam belly rolls to homemade lemonade made with love and fresh ingredients. Enjoy outdoor seating when Blue Hill Maine weather permits, and savor the taste of the coast in every bite.
9. Perry’s Lobster Shack — A Fresh Maine Seafood Experience by the Water
1076 Newbury Neck Rd, Surry, ME 04684
(207) 667-1955
About 10 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Perry’s Lobster Shack is near the water and offers the quintessential Maine dining experience. Indulge in fresh lobster served in various ways, including rolls, bisque, and pizza. Their outdoor seating provides a perfect spot to watch the boats come in and out. Perry’s guarantees a memorable feast with seafood delights, a full bar, and desserts. Well-behaved dogs are allowed on the premises.
FINE DINING
10. Arborvine — A Rustic Haven for Fine Dining
33 Tenney Hill, Blue Hill, ME 04614
(207) 374 2119
Less than half a mile from Blue Hill Inn
Arborvine is a must-visit restaurant for those seeking a refined dining experience. Nestled in a beautiful rustic setting, it is only a 6-minute walk from the Blue Hill Inn. Arborvine serves mouthwatering meals crafted with the utmost precision and care. Make sure to call ahead and make a reservation, as this place has limited seating and is a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
11. Buck’s — Where Class Meets Comfort
63 Main St, Brooksville, ME 04617
(207) 326-8688
About 7 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Buck’s combines upscale dining with a welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy freshly caught seafood, premium meats, and locally grown produce in their classy yet comfortable space. With gluten-free and vegetarian options, Buck’s caters to all tastes. Don’t miss their raw bar featuring oysters and clams from the pristine waters of Penobscot Bay, along with signature cocktails and carefully selected wines.
12. Aragosta at Goose Cove — Culinary Creativity in a Coastal Setting
300 Goose Cove Rd, Deer Isle, ME 04627
(207) 348-6900
A little over 22 miles from Blue Hill Inn
Experience culinary artistry at Aragosta at Goose Cove, where seasonal menus highlighting coastal flavors are crafted for you to explore. Choose between a 7-course tasting menu or à la carte dishes featuring local ingredients. With specialty cocktails and exquisite dishes like juniper maple porcini, dining here is a journey of taste and creativity.
Your Stay at the Blue Hill Inn
There is a treasure trove of Deer Isle, ME, restaurants waiting to be explored. Whether you crave fine dining, fresh seafood, comforting local favorites, or exotic flavors, these twelve remarkable restaurants offer diverse experiences. During your stay, consider spending a day in Bar Harbor and checking out the excellent restaurants there.
Combine the delightful flavors of Blue Hill with a memorable stay at the Blue Hill Inn, and you have yourself the perfect recipe for an unforgettable coastal Maine experience. Are you ready to start exploring the Blue Hill Peninsula top restaurants?
Check availability today. Pair the experience with upcoming events in Maine, and start creating memories that will last a lifetime.
Published March 2024
Photo Credit:
© THEPALMER via canva.com
© agrobacter via canva.com